Yoga can be bad?
19/1/12
And 'recently released on the Republic of Federico Rampini an article about the possible harmful effects of this ancient discipline. The article in question emphasizes the development of a growing and alarming so-called "syndrome of yoga accidents" that I would call malpractice syndrome yoga and Rampini himself acknowledges that even as such in the development of his article.
The topic is interesting and in fact becomes more than legitimate deal with seriousness and competence not feel it a taboo, but trying to clarify some important aspects of this question: Can yoga hurt?
Practice yoga for over 30 years and in that time I never ever had physical problems related to my practice, if anything, I can honestly say that yoga has enabled me to maintain focus and body awareness on other sports such as running, horseback riding, hiking and skiing accidents leading to numerous mechanical and physical ailments by ipersollecitazione. When I'm not well I know exactly what exercises to do and what not to do and this is absolutely true.
Certainly a case like mine is not any impact, let alone can make the text to the fact that I have knowledge of anatomy, physiology, motor recovery, achieved with my studies in medicine and rehabilitation, and with my work. It 'also true that the numbers reported in the article by Rampini really do not give the size of the problem as they are not associated with the total number of its practitioners' to the number of practitioners who are not only well but who have benefited from the practice.
That does not show a percentage of damage, much less compared with other sports or disciplines, and this does not have a complete but only partial, and dare I say "directional" and impressionable. The statement that "many people are not suited to the practice of yoga and they had better stop," and concluding that "yoga should be in good health" seems a bit excessive and biased.
Yoga is primarily a way, not just a sport, or a chance to develop something unique and useful to the individual at different levels of the individual. A good practice you can get to silence and the possibility of creating a void within themselves. The mechanical thoughts have the ability to break down freeing our minds to a much more expanded world where thought can develop, rise and travel much more freely, such as tapping into something higher.
These experiences can enrich the yoga practitioner that in this era suffer more than any other time in the sense of lack of freedom. The modern individual of today as never feels to be a prisoner of his own thoughts of many mechanical and external conditions.
Yoga is seen in this respect inside and internalized can be considered as an ointment, a medicine for many diseases including depression of the soul and the anxiety of so much talked about. And 'to consider that many sports can turn into a street. Mountaineering Messner, for example, is not only a sport but it gets in the way he practices it, a genuine way, a way to evolve, to go beyond your limits and your way of thinking creating something new as he has produced.
But as he himself says, what is good is not good for me, and indeed may be harmful and dangerous
In my experience there is nothing that is a medicine the same for everyone and everything. As if a Chinese herbal medicine herbal remedy is effective for a specific disease, the same remedy can, if taken incorrectly, to be harmful to other individuals. Being natural does not make it less harmful, is childish and puerile to think in this way.
As always it is about knowing the material in depth, not only studying but also practicing. Each posture has physical and mechanical effects which, if performed on patients with specific physical problems may be in need of fixes and customizations are not always already encoded on the individual books.
In addition, many disciplines such as yoga and Eastern religions, as many tend to remain constrained by tradition, "it was so and so do we." Teaching in danger of becoming something dead, whose value today is not the same value and as effective as one that could have at that time. Recall that the practitioner of yoga was originally selected as a child and grew up devoting a lifetime to yoga. Today it is no longer the case; also translate the ancient texts, trying to apply them and understand their meaning is not without risk to interpret.
But still not all. From experience I can say that the practice of yoga is that if you do not get to a certain kind of intensity. And 'the intensity of practice to make it effective. It is, as for many drugs and physiotherapy, a "delta effective action" sometimes very small and sometimes near the edge of potentially harmful. This makes it necessary to the prescribing medications, physical therapy practice but also to help those who practice yoga and those who do a remarkable ability to listen carefully and not to risk moving from practice to that of rose water foolish and harmful.
We enter into a dimension that it can become dangerous when the person who teaches yoga or who enters into a state of fanaticism and inability to be balanced. But let's not fool us by this new way of thinking of our modern society that wants to label everything as safe as the meat they buy at the supermarket is not so simple.
Whose responsibility if, during a lesson, the yoga practitioner who works at the supermarket lifting weights has warned all week sciatic pain worsening, and during the lesson insisted postures doing all the while feeling bad until you hear a clear sharp pain in the position of the clamp (pascimottasana), getting worse or a lumbar disc disease: the teacher or pupil?
When I was a student say, is lack of awareness of the student, as a runner who gets a knee tendon meniscopatia or because he did not stop in time. Not one has heard, has passed for ego or for distracting her physical limit and pays the consequences.
The yoga teacher becomes responsible for the consequences when his student warns him of his pain and he does not hear him or tells him to go without fear of pain and without a real awareness of the true limits of the practitioner: this becomes a failure of responsibility. It 'true that many doctors without knowledge of yoga may tell you to stop this practice as a cause of pain, without paying much attention to the subtle and perhaps destroying years of work positive. But it is equally true that the yoga teacher may not be able to understand that some of the exercises in that particular case and the situation can become dangerous inflammation: a lumbar anterolistesi for example, can worsen with extension exercises, and a lumbar or cervical rettilinizzazione disc protrusions may worsen with flexion exercises especially if maintained for a long time and these cases are very frequent and almost always produced by a sedentary lifestyle or other working conditions.
A good teacher or yoga teacher you must have studied yoga and the human body but also and above all, have long practiced and taught for too long. And him as the pupil and how many doctors should not fall into the delusion of omnipotence conferred by its role and try to keep an opinion as objective as possible.
Federico Rampini is surprised that many teachers suffer from physical ailments, why not? I say, the fact of teaching yoga for this reason does not make them invulnerable. Tensions visceral and emotional moments of unconsciousness motor can also affect them. Have achieved an awareness of an individual in a specific field does not mean it to 360 degrees and maintained on an ongoing basis.
Many pains are expressions of internal stresses and the deep and visceral reflex disorders can emerge during the practice. Discern which cases there is not easy. Running the first small and temporary orthopedic shoulder pain without waiting to see what happens, or persevere with months or years without lumbosciatica contact a specialist in the field, preferably with medical expertise, they are both errors, the first from excess of fear and the second failure of responsibility.
The balance, the right to act and speak, have the goal to be achieved; someone is still very far away, someone is already close, to err is more than understandable for both.










